My father; the wife beater.

​Reverberating sounds of slaps, punches and screaming echoes through the corridors into the room. A chaos of sounds made on and from the body. My younger sibling crawls up to me and seeks protection in my arms while I try to control my anger and the hot tears in my eyes. I am hearing my mother getting beaten and I’m powerless to prevent it . 

Quran 4:34 has given me the worst experiences and memories ever. The strings of incidents that still follows and that prevents me from being honest about who I am. I have no patience for apologists and Muslims who try and excuse this verse. I have seen it first hand many times. It is sanctioned in Islam. That is a fact. 

Yes, my dad is a wife beater. I don’t know why I am sharing this story here. But I want to speak about it, and how it was, is and will be always justified with a Quranic verse. I know the fact the Qu’ran justifies it will be hard to accept but the truth always is. 

The verse didn’t make him beat his wife. I am aware of that, but it helps him to justify his action as it is permissible to “strike ones wife if you fear arrogance from her”. But still I couldn’t always accept that as an excuse for the violence in the place I call my home. He didn’t fear Allah, didn’t think he was committing any sin by beating her.

Going between them never helps, because what happens between a man and his wife can not be questioned either. (Sunan Abu Dawood: 2142) Our most beloved prophet allowed a man to beat his wife. And apologists say he was a feminist and Islam honours women when you see so many verses that are obviously making women inferior to men.

Wife beating and all the Quranic verses and Hadiths that justifies such violence were one of the reason why I left Islam. I couldn’t stay in a religion that allows violence or inhuman activities. 

It didn’t matter what she would have done or where and how light he beat her. The only thing that mattered was Islam allowed wife beating to keep your wife in check, and make her submit to you and your needs. 

Muhammad said do not strike on the face. It’s the principle that mattered. However lightly, it’s still domestic abuse. 

 The Quranic verses that talks about wife beating: 

I know that the last Ayah talks about not breaking an oaths. But if you read the story behind it you will understand that the beating there wasn’t necessary. But to God breaking ones oath is worse than beating his wife. He didn’t care about the women’s sufferings that were about to arise from that verse.

Muhammad himself hit his favourite wife Aisha in the chest(Sahih Muslim, Book 004, Number 2127) 

Bukhari (72:715)Muslim (4:2127), Muslim (9:3506)Abu Dawud (2141) are some among the authentic justifications about wife beating in Islam. The point is it’s not a unislamic issue , in fact it’s VERY Islamic.

This is the matter in many Muslim households all around the world. My story is neither the worst, nor uncommon. Reading them are not going to stop it but it will at least encourage us to learn about the original ideology. 

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “My father; the wife beater.

  1. You cite Muslim (4: 2127) which records a dispute between Muhammad and his wife A’isha. It is recorded on all bar one of the websites I’ve looked at that, “He [Muhammad] struck me on the chest which caused me pain.” It is very interesting that on sunnah.com this phrase alone is changed to “He gave me a nudge on the chest which I felt”. Any Arabic speakers please come forward: is a word meaning ‘pain’ used in the original text? I am suspicious that this phrase has been reworded to remove a record of Muhammad striking his wife.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Im an arabic speaker. I read the hadeeth in arabic. There is no confusion about the meaning of that word which is لهدني its a struck on someones chest or shoulders or hard push. There’s no space for other meanings or sugarcoating. His wife aisha even explained that she felt pain from that struck on the chest. A nudge doesnt cause pain.

      Liked by 2 people

      • Shukran! شكرا Not a nudge then! Sunnah.com then completes the phrase with “… which I felt”, which connotes a pain which is not strong. What is most significant is that they’ve avoided the use of the word ‘pain’. Can you confirm that ‘pain’ is explicit in the Arabic rather than a milder formulation which corresponds to ‘felt’?

        Like

      • I very much appreciate your help with this. I was immediately suspicious when I saw that this phrase alone in the hadeeth had been translated differently. They have sought to conceal the Prophet’s aggression toward his wife through a wilful mistranslation as they well know that such behaviour is considered reprehensible in the modern, more enlightened age and contradicts the presentation of Muhammad as a man who was kind to his wives and to women in general.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s true, in most abrahamic religions this occurs, but Islam specifically has this issue. In any Islamic country you will see guys beating their wives, I also heard about brutal ways they beat women in middle east, like locking them up in houses, which my dad used to do.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s